Thursday
Apr232009
20 Ways to Evaluate Contributions to a Corporate Social Network
Thursday, April 23, 2009 at 8:43PM
From what I've seen, the main objectives of online social networks in companies are: to facilitate idea-sharing around a theme or topic (e.g. “Our Brand”); help users find out more about their peers; form useful insights to solve particular challenges; and for the network itself to become a useful repository of resources (ideas, inspiration, files, people) for participants.
However, the technology itself won't guarantee these results - it needs to be managed or curated effectively. Here are 20 subjective criteria I've used to help evaluate contributions to these networks:
1. Relevance to the stated objectives of the network
2. Poses questions to the group
3. Sparks discussion and comments
4. Enhances a lecture, discussion, debate or theme related to the purpose of the network
5. Makes a relevant statement
6. Responds to criticisms as well as compliments.
7. Builds on the ideas and contributions of others on the network.
8. Acknowledges the contributions of others.
9. Shares unexpected insights
10. Stories - especially from personal experience.
11. Recommendations to peers
12. Empathy - readability; humour; use of formatting; respect for other perspectives
13. Lists e.g. “Top 10…”, “Best ways to…”, “Our favourite”
14. Thought is given to topic before posting
15. Creativity or originality of ideas or the way they’re expressed
16. Clarity of expression.
17. Well structured arguments.
18. Mixes opinion and data.
19. Uses graphics to illustrate ideas
20. Contributes to the learning experience of others on the network
What you want to ultimately see is that the group is co-creating a knowledge ecosystem - so that if you want to explore any idea that catches your fancy further, you could find out who the contributors to it are.
In his book, “The Wisdom of Crowds”, James Surowieki reveals that the smartest groups are those that allow space for people to individually form and express ideas, independent of the group, which can then be “aggregated” into more cohesive solutions. This is one of the key advantages of using the online network as opposed to discussing everything in person: it allows space for more ideas around a particular topic to be expressed simultaneously.
However, the technology itself won't guarantee these results - it needs to be managed or curated effectively. Here are 20 subjective criteria I've used to help evaluate contributions to these networks:
1. Relevance to the stated objectives of the network
2. Poses questions to the group
3. Sparks discussion and comments
4. Enhances a lecture, discussion, debate or theme related to the purpose of the network
5. Makes a relevant statement
6. Responds to criticisms as well as compliments.
7. Builds on the ideas and contributions of others on the network.
8. Acknowledges the contributions of others.
9. Shares unexpected insights
10. Stories - especially from personal experience.
11. Recommendations to peers
12. Empathy - readability; humour; use of formatting; respect for other perspectives
13. Lists e.g. “Top 10…”, “Best ways to…”, “Our favourite”
14. Thought is given to topic before posting
15. Creativity or originality of ideas or the way they’re expressed
16. Clarity of expression.
17. Well structured arguments.
18. Mixes opinion and data.
19. Uses graphics to illustrate ideas
20. Contributes to the learning experience of others on the network
What you want to ultimately see is that the group is co-creating a knowledge ecosystem - so that if you want to explore any idea that catches your fancy further, you could find out who the contributors to it are.
In his book, “The Wisdom of Crowds”, James Surowieki reveals that the smartest groups are those that allow space for people to individually form and express ideas, independent of the group, which can then be “aggregated” into more cohesive solutions. This is one of the key advantages of using the online network as opposed to discussing everything in person: it allows space for more ideas around a particular topic to be expressed simultaneously.
Reader Comments (31)
Great article. Social networks are great and does really work, but you have to use them correctly. Example look at twitter now, it is in fact a great marketing tool but again only if you know how to use it or else it might become a waste of time for you with no progress.
Really found this insightful. Thanks.
Thanks for the feedback, Salwa and Elaine.
[...] via The Social Organization, such as - contributors, visitors, referrals, word count, etc. Dave Duarte provides 20 additional subjective ways to measure the social interactions in a network, including - [...]
Actual metrics that are able to evaluate the benefits of social media to the bottom line are non-existent. That makes their use by corporates rare and when they do in fact make use of social media they get it wrong. IMHO the more successful users of social media are probably your smaller organisations that operate within the online environment.
Hey Doug. It depends what you're looking for, but there are plenty of ways to measure the performance of a corporate social network - from simple page views and how many actually connections are made between people to the relative interactivity and innovation that results from its use compared to non-social networking groups in the organisation.
My company, Huddlemind, has enjoyed continued support from corporate South Africa. We host networks for small teams within the larger organisation, usually to enhance a learning intervention or organizational development initiative.
It's more a matter of how the network is set up and curated than the technology itself though, so I suppose we're more selling a service than a specific software (although the software enables the service).
Can I just say what a relief to find someone who actually knows what theyre talking about on the internet. You definitely know how to bring an issue to light and make it important. More people need to read this and understand this side of the story. I cant believe youre not more popular because you definitely have the gift.
Hi buddy, your blog's design is simple and clean and i like it. Your blog posts are superb. Please keep them coming. Greets!!!
I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success.
Hi buddy, your blog's design is simple and clean and i like it. Your blog posts are superb. Please keep them coming. Greets!!!
Thanks for sharing. Share is caring after all.
Thanks this made for intresting reading. I adore your wordpress theme, i frequently come back here and i dont know why. I just truly like your site lol... I just now read something simular to http://geeknews.me/" rel="nofollow">this i think they may well of stolen the blog?
Can you provide more information on this? take care
Hello amazing article I want to read more about it soon - http://socialnotwork.co.uk" rel="nofollow">Check out this great site
Alcohol And Drug Testing Supplies http://www.passionsongs.com/ - viagra for women name and personal details) have been edited to make the user anonymous. http://www.passionsongs.com/" rel="nofollow">cheapest viagra price My libido seemed to be increased, despite that everyone said it had no effect. http://www.passionsongs.com/" rel="nofollow">viagra no prescription
I found your site on google, It is helpful. I have added it to my favorites.
Valuable info. Lucky me I found your site by accident, I bookmarked it.
really appreciate you ,thanks a lot!
well written blog. Im glad that I could find more info on this. thanks :)
Great, I never know this, thanks, Good job My friend ;)
Good post, I can’t say that I agree with everything that was said, but very good information overall.
A tip to save some bucks when enjoying movies it that rather than going to the movie theater on a busy sunday try leasing your dvds. The regular price tag to lease a DVD is lesser than 1 / 2 the price of only one movie ticket at your average cinema. Another incentive is that you might probably rent around 4 movies from your own nearby video store for the equivalent price as 2 tickets at your movie theater.
We were was doing some research and shocked by the information you have. Read exactly what I needed too. Write more!
I was just was doing some research and impressed by the information you posted. Just exactly what I wanted also. Thx
Bridging And Drug Addition http://www.everythingpauladeen.com/" rel="nofollow">buy vardenafil - http://www.everythingpauladeen.com/ - generic levitra online Levitra helps increase blood flow in your penis to maintain an erection so you can enjoy sex without the embarrassment of losing your erection. http://www.everythingpauladeen.com/" rel="nofollow">order levitra online